Heisman Trophy Predictions & Odds 2025: Garrett Nussmeier Leads Early Odds

With the 2024 college football season over, we can already start looking ahead to 2025, which will begin in August. 

FanDuel Sportsbook has odds up for the 2025 Heisman race, and you can bet on it right now. 

Below, I’ll preview the top four Heisman trophy favorites, examine some potential underdogs, take a look back at the awards history, and more. 

Let’s dive in.

Heisman Trophy Odds

Heisman Trophy Favorites to Win in 2025

FanDuel Sportsbook is our preferred betting site for the Heisman Trophy market. Below we'll go into further details on favorites and underdogs, with currently available odds.

Garrett Nussmeier (+800) at FanDuel

Nussmeier was a redshirt junior in 2024, and it was his first season starting for the LSU Tigers. He took over for Jayden Daniels.

In his first season, he completed 337 of 525 passes (64.2%) for 4,052 yards, 29 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions. He also had three rushing touchdowns. 

In 2025, he’ll have receivers like Zavion Thomas and Aaron Anderson back, but he is losing wide receiver Kyren Lacy and tight end Mason Taylor. 

The team has also brought in Nic Anderson (Oklahoma) and Barion Brown (Kentucky) to help bolster this receiving corps. 

The Tigers ranked seventh in passing yards (315.2) and averaged 30.5 points per game. 

Bet $5, Get $200 in Bonus Bets if Your Bet Wins

Arch Manning (+900) at FanDuel

With Quinn Ewers heading to the NFL, it’s the Arch Manning show in Texas now. This comes after Texas lost in the College Football Playoff in the semifinal to Ohio State. 

Manning saw some action this season with Ewers getting injured, and he looked fantastic. 

He completed 61 of 90 passes for 939 yards, nine touchdowns, and two interceptions. He also had 108 rushing yards and four rushing scores. 

Manning will head into this season without tight end Gunnar Helm, wide receivers Isaiah Bond and Matthew Golden, and left tackle Kelvin Banks Jr. 

Now, he’ll work with DeAndre Moore Jr., Ryan Wingo, Kaliq Lockett, and tight end Spencer Shannon. 

Lockett is a true freshman who, with Manning throwing him the ball, is in a position to be the next Ryan Williams or Jeremiah Smith. 

Win a $5 Wager at FanDuel, Get $200 in Bonus Bets

Cade Klubnik (+1000) at FanDuel

Klubnik led Clemson to an ACC title, but he fell short on the road against Texas in the first round of the College Football Playoff. 

He completed 308 passes on 486 attempts for 3,639 yards, 36 touchdowns, and six interceptions. He added 119 carries for 463 yards and seven touchdowns. 

In 2025, tight end Jake Briningstool will be in the NFL, but he’ll still have Antonio Williams, Bryant Wesco Jr., and T.J. Moore to throw passes to. 

The Tigers don’t utilize the transfer portal much, but Klubnik has shown he can work with what Clemson gives him after two years of starting experience.

He’ll aim to position himself as a top draft pick in 2026. 

Get $200 in Bonus Bets at FanDuel With a $5 Winning Wager

Jeremiah Smith (+1200) at FanDuel

The first non-quarterback on this list is Smith, and rightfully so. 

As a freshman, he was the Buckeyes No. 1 wide receiver. He caught 76 passes for 1,315 yards and 15 touchdowns, and he also had a rushing touchdown. 

He came up big in the national championship game, catching five passes for 88 yards and a touchdown. 

Heading into 2025, the wide receiver depth chart will be without Emeka Egbuka, but he’ll still be working alongside Carnell Tate and Brandon Inniss has another year of experience. 

But who will be throwing him passes? It appears that it’ll be Julian Sayin, a former five-star recruit who transferred to Ohio State this season from Alabama. 

He hasn’t played any college football yet but is a highly touted prospect. 

Smith is still a few years away from being eligible for the NFL Draft. 

In the meantime, he’ll continue dominating at Ohio State. 

Grab $200 in Bonus Bets With a $5 Correct Bet at FanDuel

Heisman Trophy Top Underdogs

Julian Sayin (+1800) at FanDuel

Sayin is going to be a different-looking quarterback than Will Howard was this past season for the Buckeyes. He’s six-foot-one compared to Howard’s six-foot-four size, but by all accounts and reports, his arm makes up for any concerns you could possibly have with his body type. 

Howard gave Sayin praise, saying, "From the moment he's come in, he's tried to be a sponge. He's a quick learner and he processes really, really well for a freshman, better than a lot of guys I've seen.”  

"The dude spins a ball like I've never seen a ball get spun before. When the ball comes out of his hand, it's pretty. It looks very pretty,” he added. 

While it’s not often a first-year player, who will be a redshirt freshman, comes in and wins the Heisman, but Sayin is getting the keys to a Ferrari with Tate and Smith on the roster. 

He’s certainly worthy of an underdog selection. 

Bet $5 at FanDuel and Claim $200 in Bonus Bets if Your Wager Hits

Austin Mack (+10000) at FanDuel

Smith stole the headlines for how dominant he was as a freshman, but there was another freshman, Ryan Williams, that also turned many heads this season. 

In 13 games, he caught 48 passes for 865 yards and eight touchdowns. This was with the ever-mobile Jalen Milroe throwing him passes. 

In 2025, it’s looking like Austin Mack, a player who came to Alabama along with head coach Kalen DeBoer, will be the starter. 

In 2022, as a first-year starter in high school, he completed 70.4% of his passes for 3,498 yards, 40 touchdowns, and five picks. 

Now, the six-foot-six, 240-plus pound signal-caller will be in an offense led by a coach that recruited him and a solid group of receivers, led by Williams, to throw to. 

Alabama also brought in Isaiah Horton from Miami (FL) to help out in this receiver room. 

We’ll see if Mack can lead the Tide to a College Football Playoff berth in 2025.

Bet $5 to Get $200 in Bonus Bets With a Winning Wager at FanDuel

Top 10 Heisman Trophy Players in 2024

Garrett Nussmeier

He threw for over 4,000 yards in his first year as the starter for LSU and will have his top receiver and other weapons back. We’ll have to see how this offensive line holds up without Will Campbell, but Nussmeier should be even better in his second year as the Tigers starter.

Arch Manning

In brief action in 2024, Manning lived up to his namesake. The Longhorns have to replenish a lot of talent, but Manning could very well be on his way to leading to the Longhorns to a national title. 

Cade Klubnik

Klubnik showed some dual-threat ability on a team that doesn’t utilize the transfer portal much for talent. He had nearly 40 passing touchdowns and should put Clemson in a position to win the ACC again in 2025. 

Jeremiah Smith

He was a freshman in 2024 and had 15 touchdowns. He’ll be dominant once again with Sayin under center. 

Drew Allar

After throwing an interception that sealed Penn State’s fate in one of the two semifinal games in the College Football Playoff, Allar is back at Penn State. However, he’ll be without Tyler Warren, his top target in 2024. 

Nico Iamaleava

Iamaleava showed some flashes in his first year as the Vols' starting quarterback and has some success as a downfield passer. He struggled against pressure, but he’ll have a wide receiving corps consisting of Mike Matthews, Chris Brazzell II, Braylon Staley, and others. 

Dante Moore

The heir apparent to Dillon Gabriel, Moore transferred to the program after playing one season at UCLA. He served as Gabriel’s backup in 2024. 

LaNorris Sellers

Sellers had 19 turnover-worthy plays compared to just seven interceptions. While there was some luck, he had a yards per attempt of 8.4 yards and was willing to throw the ball downfield. In fact, he completed 48.7% of his passes on throws 20-plus yards downfield. He’s also an excellent runner, putting up nearly 900 rushing yards. 

Julian Sayin

Sayin started a single college football game but will be the starter at Ohio State with a loaded receiving corps, even with Egbuka leaving for the NFL. 

Carson Beck

Beck suffered an injury late in the year which kept him out of the College Football Playoff for Georgia and now, he’s transferred to Miami. It remains to be seen what his receivers will look like with Xavier Restrepo and Jacolby George heading to the NFL. 

Heisman Trophy History

The Heisman Trophy is voted on by 870 sports journalists, previous Heisman winners, and a fan vote. The award is given to the most outstanding player in college football, but as you’ll see below where I list all of the winners since 2010, this has turned into an award for the “best quarterback.” To add, since 2000, quarterbacks have won it 20 times. A defensive player hasn’t won it since Charles Woodson did as a member of the Michigan Wolverines in 1997. 

This trophy is essentially the MVP award of the college football season. 

The first award was given to Chicago halfback Jay Berwanger in 1935. 

See all winners since 2010 below. 

How to Bet on the Heisman Trophy

The only way to bet on the Heisman Trophy winner is to wager on the Heisman Trophy futures betting market. This is a prominent market that will change each week. You can wager on those players via player props for individual games.

Where to Bet on the Heisman Trophy

While some states restrict college player props, the Heisman Trophy winner is a futures bet and a safe betting market. That said, if you were interested in wagering in odds-on Heisman favorites through game-by-game player props, look below to see what restrictions your state has, if any. 

• Arizona (AZ): You cannot wager on college player props.

• Colorado (CO): You cannot wager on college player props.

• Connecticut (CT): You cannot wager on teams based on Connecticut unless they’re in a tournament. 

• Delaware (DE): You cannot wager on in-state teams

• DC: You cannot wager on DC-based teams or any college games occurring in the region. 

• Illinois (IL): You cannot wager on college player props. You can wager on in-state teams if done at retail sportsbooks. 

• Indiana (IN): You cannot wager on college player props.

• Iowa (IA): You cannot wager on college player props.

• Kansas (KS): No restrictions.

• Kentucky (KY): No restrictions.

• Louisiana (LA): No restrictions.

• Maryland (MD): No restrictions.

• Massachusetts (MA): You cannot wager on teams based in Massachusetts unless they’re in a tournament. 

• Michigan (MI): No restrictions.

• Mississippi (MS): You cannot wager on college player props. 

• New Jersey (NJ): You cannot wager on in-state teams

• New York (NY): You cannot wager on games involving New York-based schools or player props. 

• North Carolina (NC): No restrictions. 

• Ohio (OH): You cannot bet on college player props.

• Pennsylvania (PA): You cannot bet on college player props. 

• Tennessee (TN): You cannot wager on college player props, including live college player props. 

• Vermont (VT): You cannot wager on teams based in Vermont unless they’re in a tournament. 

• Virginia (VA): You cannot wager on college games that include Virginia teams. 

• West Virginia (WV): You cannot bet on college player props. 

• Wyoming (WY): No restrictions.

Now that you know the restrictions, look below to see what NCAAF betting sites WSN recommends for the Heisman Trophy and our exclusive welcome bonuses.

*Bonus Bets Expire in 7 Days. One New Customer Offer Only. Add’l terms.