Best MLB Parlay Picks Today: Yankees vs. Guardians Same Game Parlay For Thursday

Game 3 of the ALCS kicks off on Thursday with a matchup between the Yankees and the Guardians. New York has handled Cleveland in this series so far, but can the AL Central champions fight back? 

The Yankees won Game 1 by a score of 5-2 and defeated Cleveland again in Game 2, 6-3. New York is loaded on the offensive side of the ball, and they have been getting great production from their pitching staff this postseason.

We have three-player props that hold a ton of value in Game 3. We like Jose Ramirez, Aaron Judge, and Clarke Schmidt to have big performances. 

As a special offer, bet365 Sportsbook offers new users a $1,000 safety net bet or $200 in bonus bets. This deal is available only by following our exclusive bet365 link and using promo code WSN365. 

Let’s dive into our three-leg parlay that you can get at +320.

MLB Parlay Picks Today: Yankees vs. Guardians (5:10 PM, EST)

Jose Ramirez To Record A Hit (-220) at bet365

Jose Ramirez has been the Guardians' best offensive player throughout the past few seasons, and we expect a breakout game from him in this matchup. 

He is just 1-8 in this series, with one home run. The Yankees have done a great job of shutting him down, but he can only stay quiet for so long. 

Ramirez presents a tough at-bat for any pitcher in the league because of his multifaceted approach. In 2024, Ramirez hit .279 with 39 home runs and 118 RBIs. 

Ramirez can only be contained so long, and we expect a multi-hit game from him in this matchup. This prop is -220, but it’s a great idea to throw it in a parlay to get better odds, which is precisely what we are doing on Thursday.

Use WSN365 for $1,000 Safety Net Bet at bet365

MLB Parlay Picks Today: Yankees vs. Guardians (5:10 PM, EST)

Aaron Judge To Record A Hit (-190) at bet365

Aaron Judge to record a hit has a lot of value at -190, considering he will win MVP. The reason this line is not juiced any higher is that opponents are scared to pitch to one of the best hitters in the MLB. 

Judge has seen his fair share of free passes this season, but there will be moments in this game when Cleveland will have to pitch to him because of the situation. 

Judge has only one hit in this series, a home run in Game 2 that scored three runs. His ability to use all parts of the field and not chase out of the zone separates him from many hitters. 

Judge will always get his pitch to hit, and we think he will have plenty of opportunities in this game.

Get $1,000 Safety Net Bet at bet365

MLB Parlay Picks Today: Yankees vs. Guardians (5:10 PM, EST)

Clarke Schmidt Over 4.5 Strikeouts (+108) at bet365

To close out our player prop parlay, we are taking Clarke Schmidt over 4.5 strikeouts. Schmidt fanned four batters in his only start this postseason against the Royals on October 9th. 

He only threw 4.2 innings in this contest, and we think he will have an increased workload in this matchup, with New York up 2-0. 

Schmidt does an excellent job of getting ahead of batters and pitching to contact, which is why his strikeout prop is so low. 

We think he will finish these at-bats and put a few more hitters away in this matchup against a Guardians offense that has only produced five runs in two games. 

Look for Schmidt to limit the walks and attack hitters on Thursday. We think he can easily clear this number and will have success in this game to cash our parlay.

Claim $200 in Bonus Bets at bet365